- About   -   Contact   -   Links   -   Tools   -   Archive   -   Film -



Thursday, March 10, 2011

There has to be a breaking point for pro-environment, government-fleecing, anti-war documentaries. It feels like for every documentary about a subject not related to our abuses of the planet, the terrible atrocities and corruption caused by our war-mongering and governmental amorality, there’s twenty that bludgeon the theaters with, I’ll say it frankly, liberal propaganda. Not to say I’m complaining. A wave of films exposing the sordid activities of the Republican Party and the soon to be overheated, barren wasteland we’ve allowed our planet to become are educational, informational, and occasionally excellent in their execution. It just seems that with so many clogging the drainpipes of documentary theatrical experiences, that the films are teetering on the edge of over-saturation. Carbon Nation, a sleek new film by Peter Byck, joins the ranks of the environmental propaganda click, and suffers from the overabundance. This is a good film that opines a great idea with a certain amount of aplomb, yet struggles to distinguish itself from the mass of similarity it arrives in.






Review - Carbon Nation

Our environment, because of our inability to take care of it, is, frankly, fucked. Cars, coal, cows - they have created a percentage of terrible gasses that are not only threatening, but actively warming our climate to a point where our way of living is going to drastically, and for the worse change. Unless we do something. Peter Byck is pretty up front with his ideas in Carbon Nation - we’ve screwed the country up, here’s a bunch of ways even you, the lowly film viewer can do to help make a difference. The documentary is filmed with a certain eye for visual aesthetics and rings with an aura of humor unseen in a lot of these we-have-screwed-the-Earth’s-pooch films. Byck does well in highlighting not only the ideas and solutions to our current climate change problem, but the characters behind them. His brief portrayals of people like the one-armed wind-farmer Cliff Etheridge and determined low-income solar panel man Van Jones bring an air of humanity to our failing environment that draws us as a viewer in. If these folks, good-natured salt of the Earth people just like you and I, can do it, why can’t we? And that’s just the beginning. Byck’s film isn’t about how bad we are as a society because our environment is careening towards failure, it is about the way people are doing anything to try and bring it back from the brink. He hits all the major points in the film - geothermal, algae, wind, etc. - but brings them down to a reasonable and recognizable point. We can do something, we just have to start doing it.

A great message from a film that though flawed in its execution, was enjoyable and should be so for a great mass of scared people. From start to finish though the film works way down the same paths as nearly every other environmental documentary we’ve seen in the last two years. In its brief 88 minutes, the film tackles a wide variety of subjects, but nothing drastically different from what we’ve seen before. Carbon Nation is aesthetically attractive and moves at a quick and interesting pace, but in the end it feels like a primer for the stew of other films just like it. Quite honestly, though the good of repetition of subject matter like this is not lost on me, I’m tired of this sort of overarching environmental film. I’m tired of cheeky takes on our massive climate issues. Mr. Byck, I respect, and enjoy your film's optimistic take on the environmental crisis, I just do not know if I needed to see another movie in this vein.



- Noah Sanders -




Unless otherwise expressly stated, all text in this blog and any related pages, including the blog's archives, is licensed by John Laird under a Creative Commons License.