- About   -   Contact   -   Links   -   Tools   -   Archive   -   Film -



Friday, November 12, 2010

The story of Aron Ralston is as harrowing as anything that could be written by the best screenwriter in the entire world. Ralston, a loner-type with a yen for extreme adventure, found himself while canyoneering in Canyonlands National Park, trapped in a crack with a boulder crushing his arm. For the next five days Ralston fought insanity, thirst, and hunger while desperately attempting to free himself. In the end, Ralston was forced to cut his own arm with a cheap multi-use tool and then walk ten miles back to civilization.






Review -
127 Hours

Quite honestly, Danny Boyle doesn’t have to do much to make this an interesting film. More so Danny Boyle can’t do that much with this film, the story barely lends itself to even the slightest of change. Ralston (realistically portrayed by prolific actor James Franco) is stuck in a canyon crack with a rock on his arm and for an hour and half (the condensed 127 hours of the title) goes through every range of emotion and memory as he attempts and fails to free himself. Boyle literally places a camera in front of Franco and watches him come apart. Boyle does good work alleviating the weighty nature of the film with flashes of friends and family Ralston begins to hallucinate as the days weigh on, but truly, this is Franco’s film. And he absolutely dominates it. This is a fully fledged character, a flawed, funny, social-outsider who believes entirely in his ability to accomplish everything with out the help of others. When Ralston becomes trapped, literally pinned down, by himself, this idea quickly breaks down. Franco does a brilliant job of bringing these emotions to the forefront. What begins as desperate disbelief turns to straight desperation and then sadness and then lunacy and then survival, and with just a camera to speak to, Franco embodies all of this.

What Boyle brings to the film is the terrifying fall, the feeling of being trapped (a feeling that was so strong in the early moments of the film that I honestly felt nauseous) and of course the horrifying conclusion. Each of these big moments isn’t played with big budget glitz, but instead with a realistic reserve that hammers home the point that this could be anyone watching. With these moments well played and Franco at the top of his game, 127 Hours has all the makings of a brilliant film, but Boyle stumbles in the end, framing Ralston’s eventual escape in a cloying, almost triumphant manner that robbed the film of it’s emotional heart. Perhaps the heavy handed conclusion to the thematic arc and the throbbing music that coats the ending are ploys to leave the audience feeling heart-warmed, not terrified as the credits roll.


 

Noah Sanders is the blog/news editor at Light In The Attic and a contributor at Sound On The Sound and the KEXP blog.  He also has his own Criterion-based film site, Criterion Quest.   If you'd like to contact Noah in regards to his writings here at Side One: Track One then please do so here.


- Noah Sanders -




Unless otherwise expressly stated, all text in this blog and any related pages, including the blog's archives, is licensed by John Laird under a Creative Commons License.